Advanced Tax Mitigation Strategies, With John Hyre
Tax attorney John Hyre has built his career around helping real estate investors, small businesses, and retirement account holders keep more of what they earn. From Puerto Rico’s unique tax advantages to the pitfalls of self-directed IRAs, his focus has always been on one thing: smart, legal tax mitigation.
In this episode of The Opportunity Zones Podcast, Jimmy Atkinson and John explore advanced tax strategies that go beyond Opportunity Zones. They discuss Puerto Rico residency, IRS compliance traps, and the importance of avoiding prohibited transactions—along with John’s practical insights for investors seeking to minimize their tax burden.
Guest: John Hyre
About The Opportunity Zones Podcast
Hosted by OpportunityZones.com founder Jimmy Atkinson, The Opportunity Zones Podcast features guest interviews from fund managers, advisors, policymakers, tax professionals, and other foremost experts in the Opportunity Zones industry.
Listen Now
Episode Summary
Tax attorney John Hyre caters to real estate investors, small businesses, and self-directed IRA and 401(k) investors, with a strong focus on tax mitigation strategies. He joined the conversation from San Juan, Puerto Rico, where he has made his own personal tax move, paying only 4–6% Puerto Rican tax and no federal income tax. As he put it, living there is part of “walking the talk.”
Jimmy noted that this episode would be a little different, since it would not focus solely on Opportunity Zones. He explained that he and John had been introduced through Ashley Tyson of OZ Pros. Although John used to work with Opportunity Zones, he no longer practices in that area. Jimmy began by asking John about his views on Opportunity Zones and why he stepped away from that work.
John’s Perspective on Opportunity Zones
John emphasized that he still loves Opportunity Zones. His favorite thing about them is that they primarily attract real estate people, which is the world he enjoys working in. He acknowledged that Opportunity Zones can be complex, but compared to some of the other tax areas he has practiced in—such as self-directed IRAs—they are relatively straightforward.
At the same time, John explained why he decided to exit Opportunity Zone work. The program requires very specialized knowledge and ongoing monitoring. The rules are heavily detail-driven, and the penalties for noncompliance can be severe. He said he simply decided to focus his practice elsewhere, where he could have a greater impact for clients without the same compliance headaches.
Tax Mitigation and Puerto Rico
The conversation shifted toward John’s personal and professional focus on tax mitigation. Living in Puerto Rico is part of his own strategy. He described how Puerto Rico’s tax regime allows him to avoid U.S. federal income tax while paying a flat 4–6% local rate. This move has saved him a tremendous amount of money and exemplifies what he advises to others—finding legitimate ways to structure one’s affairs to minimize taxes.
Jimmy noted that the show had previously covered Puerto Rico’s incentives, and John added that although the programs have changed in recent years, the fundamental benefits remain powerful.
Self-Directed IRAs and Retirement Accounts
A significant portion of the discussion focused on self-directed retirement accounts. John has deep expertise in this area, having worked extensively with clients investing through self-directed IRAs and solo 401(k)s. These accounts allow investors to put retirement funds into real estate, private equity, and other alternative assets, beyond the stock market.
However, he cautioned that the rules in this area are extremely complex, and the IRS aggressively pursues violations. Prohibited transaction rules are a particular pitfall. For example, if an investor uses IRA funds to buy a property and then personally guarantees a loan, that can blow up the entire account. John stressed the importance of understanding these rules before making moves with retirement money.
Trump Accounts
John and Jimmy then turned to the newly available Trump Accounts, a tax-advantaged vehicle introduced under recent legislation. These accounts are designed to encourage long-term investment by offering preferential treatment for capital gains. When structured properly, gains inside a Trump Account can be shielded from immediate taxation and, after meeting certain holding requirements, may be withdrawn at reduced or even zero tax cost.
John explained that while these accounts are still relatively new, they are quickly gaining traction among high-net-worth investors who want an alternative to traditional taxable brokerage accounts. The ability to compound growth over many years without the drag of annual taxation makes them especially powerful when paired with other strategies like Roth conversions or Opportunity Zone investments. He emphasized, however, that the rules are highly technical, and professional guidance is essential to avoid missteps.
Advanced Strategies for High Net Worth Individuals
John next highlighted two additional tax mitigation strategies that he sees as especially relevant for High Net Worth investors.
The first is a unique method for converting Traditional IRAs and 401(k)s to Roth accounts. Most investors assume that converting to a Roth always means paying a heavy tax bill upfront. But John described a lesser-known approach that, under the right circumstances, allows for Roth conversions at a very low—or even zero—tax cost. By taking advantage of valuation discounts, timing opportunities, and careful structuring, it’s possible to move retirement assets into a Roth without triggering the full tax hit that people usually expect.
Once inside a Roth, the growth is entirely tax-free, creating what John called one of the most powerful long-term planning strategies available. For wealthy investors, this can mean millions of dollars compounding tax-free for decades, with the added benefit of flexible estate planning options.
The second strategy is the use of Rollover Business Startups (ROBS). This arrangement lets an investor roll retirement funds into a new business venture, giving them access to capital without paying early withdrawal penalties. While the idea of using retirement money to launch or expand a business may sound appealing, John cautioned that ROBS structures are fraught with risk.
They come with layers of compliance requirements, and the IRS monitors them closely because they are so often misused or abused. Even small mistakes—like sloppy record-keeping, engaging in a prohibited transaction, or failing to follow corporate formalities—can cause the entire retirement account to be disqualified. That would mean immediate taxation of the full balance, plus penalties. John’s advice was clear: while ROBS is technically an option, it should be approached with extreme caution, and in most cases avoided. In his words, “just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.”
Lessons on IRS Compliance
John shared that the IRS is especially aggressive in pursuing compliance cases related to retirement accounts. One theme he emphasized is that the IRS tends to prevail when taxpayers cut corners or fail to document their actions properly. By contrast, taxpayers who carefully follow the rules, keep meticulous records, and seek advice upfront have far better outcomes. His message was clear: it is far better to get things right at the start than to try to fix problems later.
The Role of Tax Attorneys and Advisors
Jimmy asked John about how investors should think about hiring professionals. John explained that in many cases, people try to save money by working with less experienced advisors or by doing things themselves. But in tax law—especially with areas like Opportunity Zones or self-directed accounts—that can be a costly mistake.
He recommended working with professionals who specialize in these areas, rather than generalists. The right tax attorney or CPA may be expensive, but their advice can prevent errors that would cost far more in the long run. As John put it, “Penny wise, pound foolish” is a common trap when it comes to tax compliance.
Views on Tax Policy and the Future
The conversation also touched on broader tax policy. John described how he sees Opportunity Zones as part of a larger pattern: Congress creating incentives to drive investment into certain areas or asset classes. Puerto Rico’s tax incentives are another example.
He noted that tax law is constantly changing, and successful investors must adapt. He stressed the importance of staying current and flexible. Whether through Opportunity Zones, Puerto Rico, Trump Accounts, or retirement structures, there will always be new opportunities for those willing to learn and follow the rules.
Upcoming Conference in Atlanta
Before wrapping up, John shared details about his Advanced Tax Strategies Conference, September 26-28, 2025 in Atlanta. The event will bring together attorneys, CPAs, and investors for in-depth sessions on advanced tax mitigation strategies, self-directed retirement accounts, Opportunity Zones, and related planning topics. John explained that the goal is to provide practical, hands-on education for high-net-worth individuals and professionals who want to go beyond theory and learn how to implement these strategies correctly.
He invited listeners to attend the conference and emphasized that it will be a valuable opportunity to hear directly from experts, ask questions, and connect with peers who are focused on sophisticated tax planning.
Practical Takeaways for Investors
Throughout the episode, John distilled his insights into practical advice:
- Understand the rules. Whether it’s Opportunity Zones, retirement accounts, Puerto Rico tax breaks, or Trump Accounts, know the regulations before taking action.
- Avoid prohibited transactions. With self-directed IRAs, these can be disastrous and permanently damage the account.
- Use experts. Hire specialists who live and breathe these programs, not generalists.
- Document everything. Keep meticulous records in case the IRS challenges your actions.
- Consider Puerto Rico. For some investors and entrepreneurs, relocating can be a powerful tax mitigation strategy.
- Leverage Trump Accounts. New rules offer powerful tax deferral and long-term growth opportunities for capital gains.
- Explore Roth conversions. Under the right circumstances, converting Traditional accounts to Roth can be done at little or no tax cost, unlocking enormous long-term benefits.
- Be cautious with ROBS. Just because the structure exists doesn’t mean it’s advisable.
- Don’t chase every strategy. Focus on what you can implement correctly, rather than trying to do everything.
Conclusion
Jimmy closed the conversation by thanking John for sharing his expertise and perspective. While John no longer practices Opportunity Zone law, his insights into tax mitigation, Puerto Rico residency, self-directed retirement accounts, Trump Accounts, Roth conversions, and ROBS offered valuable lessons for listeners.
The episode served as a reminder that Opportunity Zones are just one tool in a broader toolbox of tax strategies. Investors who educate themselves, work with experts, and stay compliant can unlock substantial benefits while avoiding costly mistakes.